Harassment by creditors (Scotland)
This fact sheet covers Scotland. We also have a version for England & Wales if you need it.
Use this fact sheet to:
- understand what harassment is;
- see how the Financial Conducts Authority's rules and guidance can help you;
- help you make a complaint; and
- get advice about other options for dealing with harassment from debt collectors.
The sample letter mentioned in this fact sheet can be filled in on our website.
What is harassment?
If you do not pay your debts, your creditors are allowed to ask you to pay and keep reminding you to pay from time to time. This will not usually count as harassment. However, they must not act illegally. This fact sheet will help you identify what behaviour by your creditors may count as harassment and what you can do about it. The fact sheet covers:
- how the Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) of the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) can help you with harassment;
- how the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 can help you; and
- how to deal with harassment by your creditors.
FCA's Consumer Credit sourcebook
The FCA's Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) must be followed by all companies which offer some form of credit to consumers. They must be authorised by the FCA. This includes banks, credit card companies, payday lenders, law firms, debt collectors and tracing agents.
Search the Financial Services Register to see if your company is authorised. You can search using the company's name or its postcode.
How to use the Consumer Credit sourcebook
If you think that a company trying to collect a debt from you is behaving in an unacceptable way, you can use the Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) to help you make a complaint to that company. You can also use it if you decide to complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS).
In the Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC), the FCA sets out the kind of activities and behaviour by these companies that they consider to be an unfair or improper business practice. The rules and guidance say that creditors should:
- treat you fairly;
- be clear about what they are doing; and
- give you ‘reasonable’ time to repay your debts. What is reasonable will depend on your circumstances. Your creditors may still refuse your offers without breaking the rules or guidance.
See the full rules and guidance on the FCA website, or contact us for advice.
Unfair or improper business practices
The FCA says that the following practices are considered unfair or improper.
The FCA says:
"A firm must…communicate information…in a way which is clear, fair and not misleading."
Principle 7, Principles for Businesses
- sending letters that look like court claims;
- not making it clear who the company is or what their role is;
- using unhelpful legal language;
- not giving balance statements about the debt when asked;
- not letting you know the outcome if you have disputed or queried the debt;
- contacting you at unreasonable times even when asked not to; and
- asking you to contact them on premium rate phone numbers.
False representation of authority
The FCA says:
“When contacting customers, a firm must not misrepresent its authority or its legal position with regards to the debt or debt recovery process.”
Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) 7.11.1
- claiming to work for the court or be a bailiff;
- making you think action can be taken that is not legally possible. For example, that they could take your property, enter your home or enforce a judgment without having authority;
- using a business name or logo that leads you to think they are a government body, a court or a solicitor;
- leading you to believe that court action has been taken against you when it hasn't;
- leading you to believe that not paying your debt is a criminal offence; and
- threatening to take court action in England if you live in Scotland or the other way round. *
Physical or psychological harassment
The FCA says:
“A firm must not pressurise a customer:(1) to pay a debt in one single or very few repayments or in unreasonably large amounts, when to do so would have an adverse impact on the customer's financial circumstances;(2) to pay a debt within an unreasonably short period of time; or(3) to raise funds to repay the debt by selling their property, borrowing money or increasing existing borrowing.”
Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) 7.3.10
- contacting you too frequently or at unreasonable times;
- pressurising you to sell property or take out more debt;
- using more than one collection company at the same time or not telling you when your debt has been passed to another company;
- not passing on a history of your debt including any payment arrangement you have;
- pressuring you to pay in full or in large instalments you cannot afford over an unreasonably short time;
- not giving you a reasonable time to seek advice or put forward payment proposals;
- refusing a reasonable offer of payment from you or an adviser;
- making threatening gestures or statements;
- ignoring disputes about whether you owe the money;
- trying to embarrass you in public. For example, using social networking sites or leaving inappropriate phone messages. This could also include threatening to tell a third party such as a neighbour or your family about your debts; and
- continuing to pursue the debt where it is clear you might have mental health problems which mean you cannot deal with your debts at that time.
Deceptive and unfair methods
The FCA says:
“A firm must conduct its business with integrity.”
Principle 1, Principles for Businesses
- sending letters addressed to “the occupier” or discussing the debt with someone without knowing if they are you;
- refusing to deal with an adviser acting on your behalf;
- inappropriately passing your details on to debt management companies, brokers or creditors;
- not accepting reasonable offers or passing on payments you make;
- trying to enforce the debt if you are in a debt payment scheme such as a debt arrangement scheme (DAS) or trust deed;
- refusing to freeze action or failing to investigate if you dispute the debt; or
- trying to take larger or more frequent payments than you have agreed from your account using a continuous payment authority.
Charging for debt recovery
The FCA says:
“A firm must not claim the costs of recovering a debt from a customer if it has no contractual right to claim such costs.”
Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) 7.7.2
- claiming collection costs when the original credit agreement didn’t allow this to happen and making you think you are legally liable for the costs;
- not clearly stating the amount that can be added for collection costs in the original credit agreement; and
- adding any unreasonable charges.
Debt collection visits
The FCA says:
“A firm must ensure that all persons visiting a customer's property on its behalf…do not…act in a threatening manner towards a customer…"
Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) 7.9.14
- not explaining the reason for any visit and not giving you notice of the time and date they will call;
- not visiting you if they know you are ill or vulnerable. This includes leaving if they find you are unwell or distressed;
- not coming in to your home if you do not want them to and leaving if you ask them to; and
- not visiting you at work or somewhere like a hospital.
Statute barred debts
The FCA says:
“In Scotland, a statute barred debt ceases to exist and is no longer recoverable if: (1) a relevant claim on behalf of the lender or owner has not been made during the relevant limitation period; and (2) the debt has not been acknowledged by, or on behalf of, the customer during the relevant limitation period."
Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) 7.15.3
If a debt is barred under statute, it means that by law (the Prescriptions and limitation Act 1973), the lender has run out of time to use certain types of action to try and make you pay the debt. The amount of time a creditor has is called a ‘limitation period’.
Different debts have different limitation periods, and this area of law can be complicated. If you think you have a debt that might be statute barred, contact us for advice. For more information, see our Statute barred debts fact sheet.
The Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) says that the following practices are considered unfair or improper when dealing with statute barred debts:
- asking you to pay even if you have heard nothing from the creditor during the limitation period;
- telling you that your creditor may take you to court when they should know that the limitation period has run out; and
- pressing you for payment if you have told the creditor that you are not going to pay the debt because the limitation period has run out.
Protection from unfair trading
The Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 may apply. These rules are designed to stop traders acting unfairly, including the use of what the rules call ‘aggressive commercial practices’. Trading standards has the power to take enforcement action against creditors if they break these rules.
Examples of unacceptable behaviour are:
- a debt collector pressurising you to repay a debt by contacting you at unreasonable times such as late at night or at unreasonable locations such as your workplace; and
- a debt collector threatening you with action, such as the use of sheriff officers, to recover money for unenforceable debts.
If you think you may have a complaint about your creditor under these rules, contact the Citizens Advice consumer helpline.
Dealing with harassment by creditors
Contact the creditor
- The first step is to write to the creditor and explain your concerns about the company’s behaviour. See the Creditor harassment warning sample letter.
- Tell your creditors how you prefer to be contacted. Ask them to confirm their agreement to this.
- A letter sent by recorded delivery at this stage may avoid the need to take further action against the creditor. • Tell them you are aware of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 and the FCA Consumer Credit sourcebook, and that you will consider making a complaint about their behaviour using these.
- It is worth keeping a diary of phone calls, letters, and visits and so on. Use our Sample creditor contact diary at the end of this fact sheet.
- It is helpful if another person can confirm what happened, for example when the collector called at your home.
- You may want to politely but firmly refuse to let a collector in, or not answer the phone to the collector until the problem is sorted out.
Reporting a creditor to the police
It is usually difficult to persuade the police to prosecute in cases of harassment unless a more serious offence such as violence, fraud or blackmail is also involved.
Citizens Advice consumer helpline and Trading Standards
If you want to make a complaint, you can contact the Citizens Advice consumer helpline. See Useful contacts later in this fact sheet. They will give you advice over the phone or by email. They can put you in touch with the trading standards department in your local council if you need more detailed or face-to-face advice.
Trading standards can investigate whether an offence has been committed and whether prosecution is appropriate. The penalty is a fine of up to £5,000 in the magistrates’ court. A conviction is also likely to provide evidence that the creditor is no longer a suitable company to be authorised by the FCA.
The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS)
You can complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) about how a creditor or debt collection agency has behaved when dealing with your account. The service is free and independent. FOS will look at your complaint and decide if the creditor or debt collection agency has treated you fairly. FOS can order the company to put things right, and even order them to pay you compensation. You must complain to your creditor or debt collection agency first.
For more information, see our Complaining about your lender fact sheet.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)
It may be worth contacting the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) directly on the Consumer Helpline. See Useful contacts later in this fact sheet. The FCA does not take up individual complaints, but collects information that can be used to take action against creditors.
The FCA has extensive powers, which include being able to:
- withdraw a company's authorisation;
- stop a person working in financial services;
- suspend a firm for up to 12 months;
- publicise what a company has done wrong; and
- give the company a financial penalty.
The creditor may be a member of a trade association with a code of practice. Find out if your creditor is a member of a trade association and contact them with your complaint. A code of practice is not legally enforceable, but the association may take some action against their members. See Useful contacts later in this fact sheet.
Loan sharks are money lenders who do not have a licence. This means they are acting illegally. They usually charge very high rates of interest and use violence or threats to make you pay.
There is a confidential hotline you can ring if you have borrowed from, or wish to report, a loan shark. It is very important that you get advice. Don’t be pressured into making payments you cannot afford. Check the information on the Money Advice Service website www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk. See the Useful contacts section later in this fact sheet or contact us for advice.
Blocking telephone calls
If you are a BT customer and you are finding it difficult to deal with telephone calls from your creditors, the ‘Choose to refuse’ service might help you. The service allows you to refuse calls from up to 10 different numbers. There is usually a cost for this service. If you have a different phone provider, contact them and ask if they have a similar service.
You could consider the following options in very serious cases of harassment or other illegal behaviour by your creditors. It is very important to get proper legal advice about these options, as they are complicated and can be costly. Contact us for advice.
Protection from Harassment Act 1997
Upsetting or distressing behaviour by creditors and debt collection agencies could count as “harassment” under section 8 of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997. Under the Act, you can raise a civil action to get either an ‘interdict’ (an order to stop contacting you) or a ‘non-harassment order’. Contact us for advice.
Communications Act 2003
Section 127 of this Act says that a person is guilty of an offence if they send a message with the purpose of “causing annoyance, inconvenience or needless anxiety to another”. If your creditor is found guilty, they can be fined or imprisoned.
Citizens Advice consumer helpline Phone: 0808 223 1133 www.citizensadvice.org.uk/scotland/consumer/get-more-help/if-you-need-more-help-about-a-consumer-issue/
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) Regulator for financial services such as payday lenders, banks, credit companies, insurance companies and mortgage lenders. Phone: 0800 111 6768 www.fca.org.uk/
Financial Ombudsman Service For complaints about banks and other creditors Phone: 0800 023 4567 or 0300 123 www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk
Scottish Legal Complaints Commission Contact with complaints about solicitors. Phone: 0131 201 2130 www.scottishlegalcomplaints.org.uk/
Stop Loan Sharks Advice on how to deal with loan sharks - unauthorised money lenders. Phone: 0800 074 0878 www.gov.uk/report-loan-shark
Consumer Credit Association Association for home credit lenders.Phone: 0124 431 2044www.ccauk.org Consumer Credit Trade AssociationMembers include banks, payday loan companies, mortgage lenders and debt collectors. Use their website to check if your creditor is a member. Phone: 0127 471 4959 www.ccta.co.uk
Consumer Finance Association Association for payday loan companies. Phone: 020 3178 7408 www.cfa-uk.co.uk Credit Services Association Association for debt collection agencies. Use their website to check if your creditor is a member. Phone: 0191 217 0775 www.csa-uk.com/default.aspx
Finance & Leasing Association Association for a range of consumer lending companies. Use their website to check if your creditor is a member. Phone: 020 7836 6511 www.fla.org.uk
Sample creditor contact diary
Use this diary to record every time your creditor contacts you, whether by phone, letter, or visit. This will help to show if you are being harassed.
Name of creditor or debt collection agency Date and time of contact Details of contact, for example, type of contact, what the creditor asked for and so on